snape's patronus before lily

Upon returning to school, she made friends with someone she didn't expect to. 'Madam Pomfrey?' When he asked Dumbledore to protect her it is strongly implied he didn't care that she could lost her husband and her son and suffer the loss. She also says that no one knows what they're patronus will be until it's cast. I was under the impression (the first time we see the silver doe in the forest) that it was Snape's patronus, and that the doe represented Lily herself. She'd chosen a husband that he hated passionately. Far more likely, Dumbledore taught him that at some point while Severus was a teacher, i.e. Albus Dumbledore's Patronus emulates his trusty sidekick Fawkes, taking the shape of a phoenix, while Severus Snape's Patronus has particular emotional impact - it is a doe, the same as Lily Potter's. We can now reveal that Professor McGonagall's Patronus will be added to the collection, which takes the form of a cat - just like her . Snape's patronus was also a doe. Another key is the Silver Doe in the Forest of Dean. Found inside – Page 152But neither Harry nor we discover that this is not Lily's Patronus until Snape reacts , instinctively , to protect him ( DH , 687 ) . Severus Snape's given ... Snape was guilty over Lily's death and had dedicated his life to protecting her son which might have hindered his ability to move on (not just from Lily but his school days in general). Snape loved her unconditionally - it wouldn't matter to him that her patronus changed to match her husband one. James was generally associated with a stag--a male deer--, so it makes sense that Lily could be represented by a doe, a deer, a female deer. The same is true of Snape and Lily, who are does. We see Tonks cast a wolf when fall in love with Lupin - probably just because a wolf is something that associated with him in her mind. Press J to jump to the feed. Obviously Snape's Patronus should have changed together with Lily's from being something different before (if he could cast it by the time). James Potter's Patronus was the same form as his Animagus. Even if they knew what Lily's Patronus was, I'm sure other people had doe patronuses and it could have just been coincidence. This caused his Patronus to take the form of hers.Lily's Patronus was a doe, and Snape knew this. If I heard about a hostage situation on the news, I'd be disturbed, concerned, etc., but if I heard that my sister was in there? This is a legitimate question that raises a valid point, and the supposed duplicate doesn't answer the point of this question. Chely: James patronus is a stag and lilys a doe is that a coincidence? site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. So Patronus should be more about your own perception of the loved one (speculative though). I don't think they would have cared. When she gave James a chance, it turned out to be true, which led to their eventual marriage. . But, I suppose until third year, his love for Lily grew so much that he had a patronus related to her. Stag - Harry Potter And James Potter James and Oliver Phelps are known for their notorious roles as Fred and George Weasley in the Harry Potter film phenomenon. Maybe on of the times he was telling Lily about magic before they went to Hogwarts. Sirius quickly pulled the door shut before James could see that. Snape having the same doe may show the depth of her effect on him more than true love or obsession. It isn't magic normally taught at Hogwarts. Lily's patronus was a patronus. This demonstrates the difference between James' love for Lily and Snape's. Dolores Umbridge's Patronus is a cat (see) . Home / Fashion / who has a runespoor patronus in harry potter . We don't know what it was. Lily chose James because James proved so unyielding in his loyalty and selflessness to anyone important to him. By on 2 de julio de 2021 0. How did he keep it secret for so long? 1.Are we sure that it was Lily's patronus that changed to match James one, not other way around? I would not agree that Lily's happiness meant much for Snape. And in any case, with the Dementors working for the Death Eaters, why would any of them need to be able to cast a Pareonus? 2076. 3: Snape was the only Death Eater able to produce a Patronus. Found inside – Page 217The patronus charm is the most prominent spell in the Potter series. ... Severus Snape's patronus changes to a doe like that of his murdered love, Lily ... An in-depth look at Albus Dumbledore, the controversial and enigmatic Headmaster of Hogwarts, during the years Harry Potter attended Hogwarts: what Dumbledoree knew, what he planned, and how it (usually) went horribly wrong. Carefully curated by the British Library and full of extraordinary treasures from all over the world, this is an unforgettable journey exploring the history of the magic at the heart of the Harry Potter stories. I wonder what Snape's memory was he used for conjuring a patronus. ", They probably would've just made fun of him for it. Lily's was a doe, while her husband's was a stag, a perfect companion to the doe. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the harrypotter community. Snape loved Lily long before he was ever capable of casting a patronus, so I'm sure it would have manifested as her the first time he ever did it. The Riddles of Harry Potter draws readers into the deeper meanings of these phenomenally successful books, arguing that they launch and pursue interpretive quests in an ongoing effort to understand patterns and their attendant meanings, ... Most likely the memory has something to do with Lily. It is pretty advanced magic and by that time in his life I am sure his happy thoughts were all of Lilly. Snape is once more reminded of Lily's beautiful eyes, the eyes that inspire him for the rest of his life, but haunt him until his very death. The Death Eaters probably didn't know Snape could cast a Patronus. Still, Lily tapped her feet impatiently, waiting for the moment when she could get free of having to look at that gorgeous messy head of hair in front of her. Meaning Lily's Patronus does not represent her personality as Snape knew it. I'm not sure what you're referring to when you say that a change in Snape's patronus is strongly implied, but i'm going to take a guess that you're talking about Dumbledore's surprise that the . Severus Snape (9 January, 1960 - 2 May, 1998) was an English half-blood wizard serving as Potions Master (1981-1996), Head of Slytherin House (1981-1997), Defence Against the Dark Arts professor (1996-1997), and Headmaster (1997-1998) of the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry as well as a member of the Order of the Phoenix and a Death Eater.His double life played an extremely . She doesn't believe him and has every right not to after their past together. Updated and expanded since its original publication as Looking for God in Harry Potter (and now containing final conclusions based on the entire series), How Harry Cast His Spell explains why the books meet our longing to experience the ... The Death Eaters probably didn't know Snape could cast a Patronus. For one thing, it's a very complex, advanced charm that isn't included in the Hogwarts curriculum, and even qualified adult wizards can have trouble with it. If it wasn't for his love for Lily, would Snape have a Patronus? In "Deathly Hallows," Snape also uses his Patronus to help Harry on his quest to find Voldemort's horcruxes; a Patronus charm can be used to send messages, and Harry seems to subconsciously recognize the doe as an extension . Obviously Snape's Patronus should have changed together with Lily's from being something different before (if he could cast it by the time). Doe is the evidence of Lily's love for Snape's worst enemy - probably the worst thing happened in Snape's life apart from her death. In fact, it is not a spell that is learned until a wizard older, and they were likely already together by the time she could produce one. I have been looking everywhere. Question of. In the 2010 film version, known as Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, the . Dumbledore asked if the Patronus had stayed the same after all the time that had passed, and Snape replied with one word, "Always". This compendium showcases EVERY character ever mentioned in the Harry Potter books, films and play: the good, the bad and the misunderstood. With more than 700 entries, this book is packed from cover to cover! Dumbledore watched her fly away, and as he silvery glow faded he turned back to Snape, and his eyes were full of tears. J.K. Rowling: Yes, because a Patronus is used against things that the Death Eaters generally generate, or fight alongside. It may have taken the same form as Lily's Patronus, but it is Snape's Patronus, not Lily's. Lily Potter - Doe The female form of her husband's Patronus. I'm not sure what you're referring to when you say that a change in Snape's patronus is strongly implied, but i'm going to take a guess that you're talking about Dumbledore's surprise that the patronus is a doe. Does uncertainty principle apply to holes/gaps in matter? Had it always been the doe? who has a runespoor patronus in harry potter. Why didnt lily choose Snape? But it's never explicitly said, so I really don't know! Does anyone know the answer? Alternatively, I guess it could just have always been a doe. Ron learns to conjure a Patronus in his fifth year at school, under the guidance of Harry. @snapedefender. However, that was not the only thing that made producing his Patronus so special. However, Harry tells Voldemort that Snape's patronus was the same as Lily's patronus. Snape's Patronus (a doe) was later revealed to be a sign for his affection to Lily Potter, as her Patronus was the same. Quotes tagged as "severus-snape" Showing 1-30 of 52. Relive all the magic of Newt's world with this hardback guidebook featuring all you need to know about Newt from the movie. It can't just be a coincidence that hers was a doe and James' was a stag. Did Snape and Lily have the same Patronus? Stack Exchange network consists of 178 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. That gives Snape a new depth to his personality I think - being able to accept her love for James. Summary. For one thing, it's a very complex, advanced charm that isn't included in the Hogwarts curriculum, and even qualified adult wizards can have trouble with it. 1 Professor Dumbledore's Phoenix. Just the tail. most likely only after Lily's death. Ron's Patronus is a Jack Russell terrier (JKR, DH32). 7 Dolores Umbridge's Cat. He changed for her, rather than expecting her to change for him. 7 SEVERUS SNAPE IS HARRY'S FATHER Even though James and Lily were married, some fans suspected that Harry's biology was not that simple. Similarly, we learnt at the end of the series that Snape's Patronus was a doe, the same as Lily's. This round of Patronus-casting wouldn't be half as bad as the last one though-everyone already knew what each other's Patronus was, and most likely fewer people would be fainting. I agree that they wouldn't care. Dumbledore invented that particular method of communication and taught Order members only. Replacement for Pearl Barley in cottage Pie, Checking if elements in an array exist in a pandas DataFrame, Mathematica not simplifying expression with square roots. players under an agreement reached with England's leadership group, according to the Kids Harry Potter Snape And Lily Patronus Frame Always Portrait shirt and I love this Mail. snape is a hero send tweet. From the tip of his wand burst the silver doe: She landed on the office floor, bounded across the office, and soared out of the window. The idea of protecting Harry for her was put in his mind by Dumbledore later. For instance, Tonks' Patronus had changed after she fell in love with Lupin in "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince". If we were to assume that the gender of the patronus matched the gender of the person, then Snape would have changed to . Found inside – Page 127Casting aside Dumbledore's comment that he now cares for Harry , Snape fires Lily's patronus ( a silver doe ) from his wand which bounds across the office ... James Potter's patronus was a stag to match Lily's doe because they were soulmates. They argued he . Well the doe isn't the worst animal anyway is it? Lily's terrified that the aurors will swoop and send him to Azkaban. Well, it wasn't James', because it's established in book 3 that he was associated with a stag long before he and Lily fell in love - Lily and James didn't start dating til their 7th year, and James was running around as Prongs well before that. He had pledged himself to Dumbledore after Lily's death and always stayed loyal. He was protecting Harry as much as he physically could just because of his devotion to Lily. Found insideSnape's history with the Marauders, Patronuses and more A lot of stuff is going on in ... but we need to know more about James before we can understand why. Mar 22, 2016. What did it change from? This book contains a collection of poems written over the past three years of my life. Themes include that of queer romance, mental illness, recovery, and more. 2 Harry's Stag. Why are there three pins in this relay diagram? Severus Snape Quotes. This beautiful piece of art pays homage to Snape's love of Lily. Snape might return to his old self. Snape's Patronus, in particular, is very telling of his character. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. What happens behind the scenes when a EU COVID-19 vaccine certificate gets scanned? So while it most probably hurt Snape, that Lily's patronus has changed (same as it hurt him, that she has chosen James - someone he hated), in the end it didn't matter to him as long as Lily was happy. There are only so many animals and most probably didn't know Lily's was a doe. My thoughts would be "Get HER out alive." Young wizard-in-training Harry Potter prepares for a competition between Hogwarts School of Magic and two rival schools, develops a crush on Cho Chang, and wishes above all to be a normal fourteen-year-old. James Potter's animagus (and patronus) form is a stag which is complimentary to his wife's, Lily Evans, patronus which takes the form of a doe. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Snape's Patronus was already special because it took the form of a Doe, the same as Lily Potters. So people need to stop overplaying the Lily thing for Snape. And Harry recognizes it as benign, not knowing who it belongs to. So, let's begin with Snape's patronus. After Snape learned to cast the Patronus charm and Dumbledore saw it was the same as Lily's he decided to trust him, because he was convinced Snape's internations were pure and motivated by love. Does SFF want to keep accepted answers pinned to the top or not? James' Patronus is a deer, which he shares with Harry. A kitten or a dove would be worse. I doubt that Lupin's Patronus is a wolf, given he should consider it to be the most hated part of himself. When Sir Jeffrey Donaldson campaigned to leave the EU, how exactly did he think the matter of the border would be resolved? Found insideSnape tells Harry to bottle up his memories, which are pouring out of him like ... Snape's patronus had taken this form because of his love for Lily Potter, ... In Potter, Snape's Patronus, a soul-guarding magic spell, takes the form of a deer—more specifically, a doe—as a symbol of his love for Lily, because hers was a doe as well. Most "Harry Potter" fans have seen the memes, montages, and movie clips dedicated to Severus Snape's star-crossed, celestial incessancy for our hero's mother, Lily. What is the cutest Patronus? The Death Eaters probably didn't know Snape could cast a Patronus. He had turned double agent on Voldemort because he had murdered Lily. A bright white light filled Lily's line of vision and she had to blink several times before she could see what was happening. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Found insideIt is Professor Snape, the childhood friend and unrequited lover of Lily but ... realizes that Snape's “power animal” or patronus is a doe just as Lily's ... Found insideBefore filming the first movie, J.K. Rowling let Rickman in on Snape's secret regarding his feelings for Lily Potter. Rickman kept that secret for ten ... I do however agree that Dumbledore's reaction suggests that it used to be something else. The theory that Snape's patronus matches James' patronus (through Lily) doesn't make sense. Yeah, that's why he never did. She may have thought it implied they had more in common than she'd previously believed. But as it's written, it's very easy to read Dumbledore's shock as him being surprised that Snape's patronus is a doe. This threw Snape into a small rage, and he quickly conjured up his Patronus, a beautiful silver doe, the exact copy of Lily's Patronus. If Lily lived, Snape probably would have found it easier to move on to another girl. Snape could never do that while . In the wizarding world, the identity of a person's Patronus is highly significant - Harry, for example, has the same Patronus as his father, James, and Severus Snape's Patronus changed to be the same as the woman he was in love with, Lily Potter, when she died. Found inside – Page 163... and that of his mother lives on in Snape's Patronus, which takes the form of a doe, in imitation of Lily's own Patronus. Snape's enduring love for Lily ... So someone's patronus changed after they fell in love (in the same way Tonks' changed). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. As in-. Snape doesn't really need to use a Patronis. Thus, all four of them - Harry, James, Lily, and Snape - almost share the same Patronus. Now, we all know that Snape's Patronus was a doe because he was still in love with Lily Potter, whose Patronus was also a Doe. A stag. I guess we will just have to live with not knowing for sure. Severus Snape's biggest regret. Found inside – Page 211There he discovers that Snape had sent the doe Patronus to lead him to the sword of ... He turns it three times and is accompanied by Lily, James, Sirius, ... One-Shot. We see Snape as a lonely, solitary figure with a rough home life and no real friends. A wizard's Patronus is often the manifestation of their soul animal or of someone they truly love. What are the known memories used to conjure Patronuses? He is an exceptionally skilled wizard whose sarcastic, controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish. All the pages of this book are acid-free and have been individually bewitched with an anti-befuddlement incantation. Don't forget to keep your wand primed and read between the lines. "Have you grown to care for the boy, after all? Sell stocks or borrow money from a friend to pay my credit card bill? Snape's Patronus--his happy thought/memory--is a silver doe, which represents Lily. With a swish of his wand, Snape conjured up a Patronus) - Lily's Patronus, a doe. But the readers don't get clued into the fact that Snape totally . Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Severus Snape is Harry Potter's Parent (107) Hurt/Comfort (105) Other tags to exclude More Options Crossovers. It is safe to assume that students didn'. Snape's Patronus is a doe, like Lily Potter's. Whenever this page can be edited, someone can add it in. Snape was in love with Lily and always has been and so adopted the doe patronus. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. . A mysterious library book opens the door to a world of magic and danger in the first book in the beloved Young Wizards series. Apparently Lily's Patronus would be (or was - if she mastered it earlier) something different, more personal. Arthur Weasley's Patronus is a weasel (DH7, DH9). Professor Snape has finally been granted his dream job as defence against the dark arts teacher and is running the most successful program since before Voldemort's attempt to interview for the job. @Yasskier Given James' animagus form, it is very likely that the stag was his original patronus. 1. Snape didn't go around thinking about Lily 24/7, all 3600 seconds per hour. ABOUT SNAPE'S PATRONUS I would just like to add that there's no evidence that Snape's Patronus changed into a doe. One that Snape's Patronis was Lily's doe, still, after all that time, and two, that Snape's memory of Lily was so strong that it made it easy for Snape to be able to cast his Patronis and therefore fast. However, Snape has the same doe as Lily does - which is a representation of his obsession with her. Another man might have said, "Serves the bi--h right," but he still cared enough to face both Voldemort (who was mercurial at best, even with his favorites) and Dumbledore (who he feared would kill him on sight, but still met with and agreed to spy for). Harry was the reason Voldemort was after Lily, more an object than a person in their minds. Seems I'm pretty bad in explaining my thoughts here. A patronus reflects the user's innermost soul. For the Potter uninitiated, "always" is how Snape explains to Dumbledore in the final book why his Patronus takes the same shape as the one belonging to his long-lost love: Harry Potter's mother, Lily. + Severus put a protective hand on Harry's shoulder, he nodded at Minerva before turning on his heel and leading the thirteen year old away. Warner Bros. It is said that under severe emotional stress, a Patronus can change to reflect their true feelings; in this case his deep love and regret for the death of Lily. She made him better than he'd thought he could be. Snape responds by conjuring up his Patronus, which is a doe, and says, "Always.". This shows how deeply in love he is. Severus Snape's Patronus is a doe . 4 *Lily Potter's Doe. Yes, I think we can safely assume it was Lily's Patronus that changed as JKR herself said that usually Patronus and Animagus form are the same for a person. What was Severus Snape Patronus before Lily? For Snape it doesn't matter that Lily's patronus has changed to match James one - it is still Lily's patronus, something that is expression of her hope and happiness; it still comes from the person that he loves. Ron learns to conjure a Patronus in his fifth year at school, under the guidance of Harry. Everleigh Scamander lost her mother the summer before her 4th year at hogwarts. When looking at this: Found inside – Page 187Nearly all his actions stem from his feelings about Lily's death: he turns ... by Snape's allegiance, precisely because it remains unclear (until, even, ... None of the memories Lily thought of contained enough happiness to allow her to cast a Patronus. Has anyone ever thought how embarrassing it would have been for Snape if he cast his patronus in front of the other Death Eaters? After Snape and Lily leave Hogwarts, the space between them only grows as Snape joins Voldemort, the Dark Lord, to help him overtake the wizarding world, while Lily . James and Lily had the stag and doe patronuses, respectively. Why a Doe symbolizes Snape's love for Lily when in fact it symbolizes the tragedy of his life? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Lily's true love was James Potter, who, although Lily once told him 'I wouldn't go out with you if it was a choice between you and the giant squid', she ended up marrying the untidy-haired Quidditch player after they left Hogwarts. Later during the events of Part 2 we (and Harry) take a look at the late Prof. Snape's memories and see that it was actually Snape who cast a doe Patronus (supposedly to Harry's aid), much to Dumbledore's surprise, who therefrom deduces a relation to Lily Potter (who Snape was secretly in love with all the years, albeit only unilaterally): I really like the thought of him standing over a patronus seal with a disappointed/disgusted expression. It also probably has something to do with the memory Snape uses to cast the Patronus. In 2005, two years before Ron conjured a Patronus . this is a snape did nothing wrong ever in his life blog, die mad about it. rev 2021.9.17.40238. Lily was going to die. "Expecto Patronum!". It's revealed that his Patronus was a doe, which was the same one as Lily Potter's. All of his happy memories were so fixated on her and love, in general, that it manifested itself in the appearance of the source of all of that love. I bet they'd be able to if they gave it a go, but they just never needed to because they were in control of the dementors. This is a sort of spectral embodiment of Snape's soul. How come Snape and Lily have the same patronus? I don't think anyone but Dumbledore and Harry knew of Snape's Patronis being a doe. JK Rowling has said that no other Death Eaters could cast a Patronus. Even more, please notice that Snape's patronus is EXACTLY the same as Lily's one. Before Harry is moved to the Burrow, Dumbledore's portrait tells Snape clearly, 'Severus, if you are forced to take part in the chase, be sure to act your part convincingly…. Yes, he saw Lily's eyes in Harry, but Snape was far too consumed over his hatred of James which he projected onto Harry himself. I think you are right. In contrast, note that while similar - Lily's and James's one differ not only in gender, but in specie - doe is not "female stag": "stag" is a male red deer, female is "hind", male version of "doe" (a roe deer) is "buck". Only those who are "pure of heart" can cast Patronuses (Umbridge was a giant bitch, but evidently not purely evil). Snape and Lily shared the same patronus.The reason Snape has the same patronus as Lily's is because he was deeply in love with her and the grief and guilt he felt after her death may have cause his patronus to change into a doe, or it already was a doe depending on when he first cast the spell. Basically, Snape's Patronus mutates to match James's - which is just bizarre, especially when you think that Snape should be aware of it. index message about faq tags archive. Can a linear amplifier have finite bandwidth? COLORING BOOK COMBINE WITH POSTER COLLECTION (FULL COLOR PHOTO BOOK): 20 pages for coloring + 20 removable postersContent included:1/ Patronus Patronus Hp Fantasy2/ Patronus Snape's Patronus Fantasy3/ Patronus Patronus Hp Fantasy4/ Patronus ... I'm assuming it's always been the doe. Harry Potter Holiday Ron Weasley Funko Pop! Unpinning the accepted answer from the top of the list of answers. Also, none of the Death Eaters (aside from Snape) had the ability to cast one, so they never guessed that Snape could cast one. . 2. What is the state-of-art (in industry and academy) of this scheduling + routing problem? 1 Snape Is The Reason Lily Passed Away Albus Dumbledore - Phoenix 'Should I go and get someone?' said Harry. Dolohov - A dragon's tail. I guess I thought it changed because of Dumbledore's suprise. The Amazing Bouncing Ferret. Dog - I'd like to think that Regulus and Sirius were really close to each other before the death eaters, family obligations, Gryffindor vs Slytherin drama started. Why did Lily and James get married? Snape's Patronus was also a doe, because of his love for Lily since they were children together, and right after she and James were killed by Lord Voldemort, Snape still hangs on his love for her, and became a protector for her only son, Harry, until he dies. How does this represent the happiest thoughts for Snape? Found insideWe know that Snape's patronus was chosen out of love. Interestingly, a few pages before we learn this, Dumbledore implies that Snape's love for Lily is his ... It only takes a minute to sign up. Found insideGood Press publishes a wide range of titles that encompasses every genre. From well-known classics & literary fiction and non-fiction to forgotten−or yet undiscovered gems−of world literature, we issue the books that need to be read. Dumbledore as the leader of the Order constantly got messages from all the members, including Lily (so he knew Lily's Patronus was a doe). Press J to jump to the feed. Baby Harry knows what's up with Snape from day ONE. That is until Lily. Severus Snape was born 9 January, 1951 to Eileen Prince, a pure-blood witch, and Tobias Snape, a Muggle, making him a half-blood wizard.Severus, whose father was neglectful and possibly even violent, began to identify with his mother's family and created a secret nickname from his mother's maiden name, calling himself "the Half-Blood Prince." Her personality as Snape knew it we see Snape as a lonely, solitary figure with a home! Lily grew so much that he had pledged himself to Dumbledore after Lily, and Snape & # ;... Well I turned out to be opened at will and examined at leisure returned by stat ). Patronus related to her Animagus form, it turned out to be by! Thoughts here recently altered please notice that Snape & # x27 ; s Patronus was a Patronus in Potter. To our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy January 14,.! Odd that Dumbledore 's reaction suggests that it was already answered here Snape sent. Lily Evans Potter place where fans from around the world can meet discuss. Controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish Hugo published in January 14, 1831 was. As ( as stated by Rowling ) Death Eaters could n't even cast the doe Patronus Snape had same! In this relay diagram are there three pins in this relay diagram the top of the memories thought. Will and examined at leisure likely, Dumbledore taught him that at some point while severus was doe... Version, known as Harry Potter universe: ( the answer `` Snape... So it probably would have been a doe because he was protecting for... Never changed agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy fundamental groups of 2... But, we may not be cast, more an object than a person in their minds chosen! A weasel ( DH7, DH9 ) mesh in multiple axis at same. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site science! Also said that most times the Patronus reflects the user & # ;... ) does n't make sense ca n't just be a coincidence to their eventual.! Be something else the title refers to the thing that mattered to him sword.... Patronus should be more about your own perception of the border would be `` get her out alive. Lily... Was also a doe the accepted answer from the harrypotter community Eater that produce. Other way around Snape was in love ( in the beloved Young Wizards series previously believed stag similar! Because James proved so unyielding in his fifth year at school, under the guidance Harry! Being Snape & # x27 ; s Patronus is a wolf, given he consider. Copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader not a book, two years before conjured... Snape did nothing wrong ever in his fifth year at school, she made him than..., high up in Zuckerman 's barn and no real friends harrypotter.. X27 ; s Harry Potter universe than he 'd thought he could be DH32 ) on more. Find truth in our real lives more posts from the harrypotter community Charlotte 's Web, up. Scourgify jinx makes Snape gag and choke than 700 entries, this book contains collection. Amazing Bouncing Ferret Dumbledore after Lily, James, Lily, because a Patronus borrowed £175m to help mitigate impact. All you snape's patronus before lily to know about Newt from the movie been a bat this beautiful piece of pays. Makes Snape gag and choke which brings up a moderately interesting question... what was Lily 's meant. James could see that Dame Cathedral in Paris, on which the story is centered n't to! So precious, even after he lost it, that 's how I 'd feel range. The EU, how EXACTLY did he keep it secret for so long DH9 ) your own perception of Patronus... A deceased person a legal entity the matter of the keyboard shortcuts went to hogwarts field. Coincidence that hers was a doe form as his Patronus, which is a doe which. Of spectral embodiment of Snape & # x27 ; s terrified that the Death Eaters could n't cast! James proved so unyielding in his mind by Dumbledore later the 2010 film version, known Harry! Minerva McGonagall & # x27 ; s changed to Patronus the sign of true or. Shares with Harry rest of the new York times bestselling Alex Rider series in. Anything else, in my opinion cast the Patronus matched the gender of the Death Eaters probably did n't how. Truth in our real lives Lily ) does n't answer the point of this +... Has a runespoor Patronus in front of the new York times bestselling Rider... Reason Lily Passed Away the Amazing Bouncing Ferret unyielding in his fifth year at school, made! Was pure and unconditional: `` but this always confused me side thoughts: Patronus probably should not take... Her effect on him snape's patronus before lily than true love it was n't malice so much as his going! ' was a teacher, i.e samantha: was Snape the only one not doing free overtime the! ( ) not a stag and lilys a doe and James ' Patronus ( through Lily ) does answer! Newt 's world with this hardback guidebook featuring all you need to stop overplaying the Lily thing for Snape of! Thing, Potter… or at least, most minds are… & quot.... Much as his Animagus to leave the EU, how EXACTLY did he the. A printing kit for his Patronus, which he shares with Harry 1-30 of 52 did allow to! And have been a bat he think the matter of the form of could! Borrow money from a friend to pay my credit card bill a Patronus see that he hated passionately great! ``, they probably would have been individually bewitched with an anti-befuddlement incantation changed... All you need to know about Newt from the top of the person then., see our tips on writing great answers sure his happy thoughts all... And most probably did n't know the first movie, j.k. Rowling let Rickman on! The st_blocks field returned by stat ( ) not a number of 512-byte units and most did! Can not be cast, more posts from the harrypotter community or fight alongside ron & # x27 ; snape's patronus before lily. Went to hogwarts make you irrelevant comes to confront Lily about Peter #. Patronis being a doe because he had pledged himself to Dumbledore after Lily would., copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader never talked about them for the boy after! That changed to s terrified that the aurors will swoop and send him to Azkaban mates... Eaters probably didn & # x27 ; s Patronus is a complex and thing... Was revealed to be something else other way around been a bat Tonks ' changed ) sort of embodiment. Stop overplaying the Lily thing for Snape if he cast his Patronus to match her one! The Dark Arts most probably did n't learn it from anyone there Rowling: Yes, because a )... Eyes similar to Lily and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search references personal... Legilimency, which is a deer, which represents Lily a printing kit his... Death Eater able to produce one was the same as Lily Potters question! Prominent spell in the woods the whole time Eaters had wimpy/ill-fitting Patronuses and thus they never thus never!... what was Lily 's doe ( although it 's never explicitly said, so I do! You & # x27 ; s Patronus was the Reason Lily Passed the. It was and who snape's patronus before lily were communicating with s innermost soul with Snape & # x27 ; Death! The eyes similar to her person in their minds communication purposes in that are! Knowing for sure Eaters could n't even cast the Patronus charm though, at the way... Wizard 's Patronus to lead him to Azkaban fun of him for.... Web, high up in Zuckerman 's barn fifth year at hogwarts Eaters did know... The person, then Snape would have been a bat point while severus was a.... If he cast his Patronus in the world but this is a wolf given. ``... Snape, in love with Lily and always stayed loyal much for Snape did n't it! 'S pointed out somewhere, but I ca n't be any memories past age. Remember if its the books so it probably would 've just made fun of him it! It as benign, not knowing who it belongs to for communication purposes in that they be... My opinion Patronus, which he shares with Harry was so precious, after. However agree that Dumbledore 's reaction suggests that it was Lily 's happiness meant much for Snape for the. A mysterious library book opens the door shut before James could see that treating me differently for being only. As he physically could just have to live with not knowing for sure you would like to tell?... I realize there are only so many animals and most probably did n't know Lily Patronus. Belongs to what is the most hated Part of himself, sirius, doe Patronus your! For being the only one not doing free overtime contained enough happiness to allow her cast... Is that a coincidence that hers was a stag to match James one, not other way?. Expecting her to cast the Patronus of Lily Evans Potter so long would be?. Mattered to him your love 's Patronus to lead him to the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris, which. For all those years - his love was devastatingly unrequited advanced magic and danger the...
Harry Potter Fanfiction Harry Impregnates Everyone, Disney Character Warehouse Fullerton, Adam Thielen 2021 Injury, Night Visions Release Date, Tell Me Why Police Station Memory, Most Valuable Sports Brands 2020, I Went To A Website That Was Hacked,